Friday, March 27, 2009

A glimpse into my paper

I wrote a large portion of my paper today.  I thought I would post what I have so far for some criticism.  I haven't edited anything yet or written a conclusion so its still pretty rough.

The Memory, Imagination, and Soul of Mythtelling

Sean Kane writes in his novel Wisdom of the Mythtellers “[…] myths were not merely flights of the imagination; they were flights of the spirit, with the narrative acting as the conduit of supernatural energies summoned and made present by story, and the mythteller acting as the conductor of the souls of the listeners” (104).  But why did mythtellers control such power?  Paraphrasing Aristotle, Francis Yates writes “memory…belongs to the same part of the soul as imagination; it is a collection of mental pictures form sense impressions but with a time element added, for the mental images of memory are not from perception of things present but of things past” (33).  In an oral tradition, storytellers held the key to personal development, morally, socially, and spiritually.  They molded the youth of the tribe.  They taught future leaders, future shamen, and future farmers the knowledge needed to survive in a threatening world.  Stories capture the imagination, and according to Aristotle, imagination connects with memory.  Both memory and imagination lie in the soul and as a result, the storytellers guiding the soul become the single greatest influence on the development of the mind.

  Myths teach people how to interact with the world.  “Exchange with the world is made at the mouth, nose, ears, eyes, anus, sexual organs, and the skin itself” (Kane 103).  Before print, myths were used to teach children about poisonous berries, the weather, planting crops, and medical uses for plants.  These myths appealed to the imagination as colorful characters acted as the guinea pigs of the natural world.  For example excess pride will cause downfall as in the story of Icarus.  Because memory coexists with imagination in the soul, myths remain in the collective consciousness of the tribe continuously teaching the important lessons of development.  Initially, these stories guide developing souls through imagination and memory however, the mythteller’s true gift extends beyond practical knowledge.  The storyteller and his myths play a crucial part in the development of knowledge.

Paraphrasing Plato, Yates writes:

The Phaedrus is a treatise on rhetoric in which rhetoric is regarded, not as an art of persuasion to be used for personal or political advantage, but as an art of speaking the truth and of persuading hearers to the truth.  The power to do this depends on a knowledge of the soul and the soul’s true knowledge consists in the recollection of the Ideas.  Memory is not a ‘section’ of this treatise as one part of the art of rhetoric; memory in the Platonic sense is the groundwork of the whole. (37)

 

Plato’s theory of forms states that all knowledge comes hardwired into the brain upon birth.  Accessing this information requires little more than the proper thought or more specifically, proper rememberence.  Truth depends on the knowledge of the soul and its two main aspects, memory and imagination.  If truth lies in the soul, then the person responsible for developing the soul holds the key to knowledge.  Enter the mythteller and his true purpose in mythtelling.  Because myths develop the memory and imagination, they offer the gateway to not just practical knowledge but all knowledge of the past, present, and still to come.  Cicero argues for the power of memory and imagination, “assuredly nothing can be apprehendend even in God of greater value than this … Therefore the soul is, as I say, divine, as Euripides dares say, God …” (Yates 47).  Thus, the power imparted by an oral mythteller through his stories surpasses the power of god.  Stories that teach what is, what was, and what will be empower a human with the divine, which explains why religion roots in myth and storytellers become demi-gods.  After Plato and Aristotle, figures appear scattered through history who realize the power in stories, soul, memory, and imagination like Camillo, Lull, and Bruno, however the mythteller tradition has faded in the modern era.  Yet, even today, residual orality and residual mythtelling remains.

The residual influence of the oral storytelling tradition, though not as formal and reveared, appears in childhood development today.  Countless studies indicate that exposing young children to aural stimulus aids development.  Reading fairytales, listening to classical music, and speaking other languages work in a similar fashion today as myths did thousands of years ago.  “Sound is thus a unifying sense,” writes Walter Ong in Orality and Literacy “[…] knowledge is ultimately not a fractioning but a unifying phenomenon, a striving for harmony.  Without harmony, an interior condition, the psyche is in bad health” (71-72). “Sound […] exists only when it’s going out of existence” (Ong 90). It is up to the imagination to comprehend something that only exists instantaneously.  The imagination must connect a sound to a concrete object or visualize a sound as an action.  While the imagination processes sound, memory stores it and the soul critiques the whole experience. Reasonably, exposure to aural stimulus begins the development of the “unifying phenomenon” called knowledge.  Knowledge, that is, according to Plato, a product of the workings of the imagination, the memory, and the soul.

9 comments:

  1. Kevin. I'm not sure if you're done with the paper, but it's really good. I know you've been kind of bent (in a good way, as happens to all of us) on the memory, imagination, soul package, and you did a good job of linking the three by also explaining their importance, as well as that of the myth teller. (You also mentioned how religion is based on myth...I wonder, tangentially, if the real holy trinity is memory, imagination, and soul?) Anyways, you know what you were trying to do, and you did a good coherent job of it. Would you like to write my paper?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kevin, I think you chose a great topic for this paper because clearly you are very interested in it. I dig your whole layout, you do a great job of connecting the memory, imagination, and soul throughout your entire paper. I also liked how in the end you began to talk about how this functions in our society today, I think you should add more to that, give it a little more love. Myth telling seems to be a dying past time but your bring it back to the present, go further with it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am very impressed with the circular connections that you made with the soul, imagination, and memory as a pathway to the knowledge of the divine. Your paper brings to light all the notions of enlightenment as a completeness of the self. We are told in biblical terms that God gave man everything he needs to survive the turmoils of life, and your paper offers what some of those survival tactics might be and where they may have come from. I enjoyed your connections very much and hope that you will further expound (if you can) upon further notions of the connections between memory, soul, and imagination.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kevin. Great work. I especially liked when you gave examples of how the influence of residual oral story-telling is still prevalent in today's world. The only suggestion I have is to maybe bring in a source other than what we have read for class...? But other than that I think your paper is excellent.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I also enjoyed the read, Kevin. What I would maybe like to see more of is some deeper insight into the divinity of memory,imagination, and the soul as well (sort of along the lines of Sutter's thoughts about the trinity if you want to take it that far, but I'd understand if that was too much to tackle). I put a quote up on my blog that would maybe spark some more ideas in your head about the divine words/sounds that float around inside our head and make us remember and imagine. You're on to something powerful here, my man, so bravo and keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
  6. It's Christopher (Christoper....Oper ;) by the way.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is a great concept for a paper and it sounds like you have a lot of knowledge on the subject. I think that with this paper plus the group presentation, you're bringing some great stuff to Oral Traditions. In years to come they will speak your name, if only in a whisper...Bright Eyes Kevin!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Well done man. Really well thought out, and you used some excellent quotations. I'm actually excited to hear the three minute presentation. Should be fun.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great paper topic man! I find it really interesting, this Three-foldness of personal experience if you will. Imagination in the present feeds on both past memory and "that creative part of a person" (soul); simultaneously the encoding of new memory in the present is in part based on imagery (imagination) and meaning (soul). Etc.

    I've heard that Plato talked about another "three-foldness" of human endeavor/experience which he called the True, the Good, and the Beautiful. Later people have expanded on that to say Science, Morals, and Art; the World, the Society, and the Self, etc. Might these have some connection to Memory, Imagination, and the Soul? Just a random thought,

    ReplyDelete